Damask Tumblr Themes

Link Post Thu, Jul. 19, 2012 568 notes

Do You Live in a Bubble? A Quiz | PBS NewsHour

soultired:

drumkey255:

sanityscraps:

casecous:

surelyforthvakarian:

havissard:

annaetc:

anniehinton:

sotheresthat:

catsavoie:

I scored a 39. I saw it coming. I grew up in NW DC (although, back in the 80s, DC was hardly what it is now), have never watched a full episode of Oprah, Dr. Phil, or Judge Judy, and don’t have the attention span to be a big movie buff. But I do own a Jimmie Johnson shirt (it was more of a drunken purchase at NASCAR than an ironic one, too).

What’s your score?

I got a 56. I grew up super rural, blur collar breadwinner, the whole nine yards. Some of these questions are pretty hilarious. I wonder if a milking parlor counts as a “factory floor”?

I got a 46, this sort of thing is incredibly interesting to me. Coming from a working class (low low income) family in Iowa to working in a law office in Chicago where the clientele is mostly North Shore divorce clients, I can see that great divide often. 

I scored 25, straddling the line between “A first-generation upper-middle-class person with middle-class parents” (typical score: 33) and “A second-generation (or more) upper-middle-class person who has made a point of getting out a lot” (typical score: 9). Ayep.

Pretended I was American, answered all questions as though I’d lived my life in the US, and got 59.

69: A lifelong resident of a working-class neighborhood with average television and movie going habits//A first-generation middle-class person with working-class parents and average television and movie going habits. 

17:  A second-generation (or more) upper-middle-class person who has made a point of getting out a lot. Typical: 9.

25: A second-generation (or more) upper-middle-class person who has made a point of getting out a lot. Typical: 9.

Not surprised, I guess. I do kind of fail pop culture, but I never really connected it with class until now. Huh.

You got 63 points: 48–99: A lifelong resident of a working-class neighborhood with average television and movie going habits. Typical: 77.

42–100: A first-generation middle-class person with working-class parents and average television and movie going habits. Typical: 66.

11–80: A first-generation upper-middle-class person with middle-class parents. Typical: 33.

I got a 15, and I kiiiiind of fit the description of “0–20: A second-generation (or more) upper-middle-class person with the television and movie going habits of the upper middle class. Typical: 2” except I pretty much never go to the movies because so many are misogynistic or otherwise bigoted and especially after the film industry rallied around a child rapist, and a lot of the others are accounted for me being a general shut in.  I know that fits the description, but it seems like the results are geared more towards “You are social but avoid mainstream things because of your privilege” as opposed to, “You are asocial and watch the same 20 tv shows over and over while surfing the Internet.”  I also don’t drink period (for fear of family alcoholism and because of medication), but I do eat a lot of processed food because I can’t afford much better, so maybe I should have scored there? 

It seems like this poll neglects, at the very least, how disability affects some of the questions.

Also this is from the asshole who wrote the Bell Curve.

I got 53. I am certain my score would have been higher if I weren’t disabled. And in fact there are also things that lowered my score because I am too poor to do them, which kind of defeats the point of the quiz. (It’s rare I can go out to eat or go to the movies, and I’m sure as hell not buying a pickup.) And I’m not employed so wouldn’t be wearing a uniform. If I answer a couple questions in terms of my family rather than me I get 59 so not much difference though.

I grew up thinking I was middle class, but I’m now told that I was more like upper working class. Because apparently there’s an area where the working class overlaps the middle class in terms of income (like we actually made less than some plumbers, even with my mom working more than one job), and apparently the power structure of my parents’ jobs is more working class than middle class. We lived in a mixed middle/working class neighborhood but I went to a private school with mostlyupper middle class kids that I thought were all rich. As an adult I’ve always been poor due to disability, and have lived in low income areas by necessity.




COMMENTS
  1. laughlikea reblogged this from talwaar
  2. houndedingotham reblogged this from iamdrawberry and added:
    65 points. “A first-generation middle-class person with working-class parents and average television and movie going...
  3. learningtoricochet reblogged this from laughingasongox and added:
    28 - I’m 22 and from Long Island. Went to college in Manhattan and have only ever lived in a major city or the suburbs...
  4. n-a-r-i-e reblogged this from boysinperil and added:
    I got 10. Surprising no one, I’m pretty sure.
  5. lurkinmerkin reblogged this from boysinperil and added:
    I got a 62 myself. Glad to confirm that my bubble is thin, lol. EDIT: That said, thinking about the quiz further, I...
  6. boysinperil reblogged this from panaili and added:
    I got a 67. I grew up in a small town and come from a blue-collar background; I’ve held a number of jobs that make me...
  7. panaili reblogged this from beautyinthespacebetween and added:
    I graduated college in 2008 with a dual degree in Japanese and International Relations and predicted the cold, black...
  8. beautyinthespacebetween reblogged this from panaili and added:
    Ooh, cool. I always like learning about people who are in the military. How did you get involved?
  9. chilope reblogged this from laughingasongox and added:
    70- I’ve always been poverty stricken and shit.
  10. thesubtlegatsby reblogged this from preludeofthebreath and added:
    31. “A first-generation upper-middle-class person with middle-class parents.” pretty much, yeah
  11. preludeofthebreath reblogged this from poppinpussiesintopies and added:
    44. 1st gen middle class, right here! :P
  12. laughingasongox reblogged this from poppinpussiesintopies and added:
    20- I’m 18 and from Long Island.
  13. poppinpussiesintopies reblogged this from mcmexican and added:
    18 - I’m 15 years old, I live in San Francisco and spend extensive amounts of time in Berkeley. I wouldn’t expect my...
  14. thelalatheory reblogged this from titivil and added:
    Right! That’s what I said! The freaking Bell Curve, man!
  15. prettyodd6 reblogged this from maryanne and added:
    57, lol michigander for lyfeee
  16. sarahisbetterthanliz reblogged this from markcoatney
  17. td-tinydancer reblogged this from meredithbklyn and added:
    45
  18. meredithbklyn reblogged this from haygirlhay and added:
    I know I’m late to the party, but I got a 35. Interesting questions.
  19. gumonasidewalk reblogged this from sanityscraps
  20. chiaberry reblogged this from thatfrenchman and added:
    I got a 49. Spending my elementary school years in Farmville, VA (pop thatfrenchman:
  21. ginmpotter reblogged this from prepstergrunge and added:
    36. A first-generation upper-middle-class person with middle-class parents. A second-generation (or more)...
  22. prepstergrunge reblogged this from nickdouglas and added:
    40. Either categorized as a second gen upper middle class person (which I’m not) trying to get out a lot (which I do) or...
  23. eikonodoulos-askesis reblogged this from abaldwin360 and added:
    I also pretended to be an American and I got 30. A second-generation (or more) upper-middle-class person who has made a...
  24. vindikateor reblogged this from kvknowsherfun and added:
    I got a 60. And I’m so confused by what the scoring reveals.
  25. athreateninghaiku reblogged this from skepticalavenger and added:
    i’m surprised i only got a 58 because taking this made me feel like a poor redneck. i don’t want to know who that jimmie...
  26. cjsoapbox reblogged this from laughterkey and added:
    45 if i exclude being miserably broke during college. 49 if I do include it. I’m going to that to being an Army brat....
  27. byvirtueofyourgrace reblogged this from sarahfonseca and added:
    I got 29.
  28. coffintramp reblogged this from skepticalavenger and added:
    really only watch TV/out-of-theatre movies when I’m with other people lately. 48–99:
  29. lauratheoutlandish reblogged this from caro and added:
    almost… 31. Yep. Pretty bubbly.
  30. lordubu reblogged this from nickdouglas
  31. moosicus reblogged this from nickdouglas
1/1